Scoring Guide for Art Historian

4 Exemplary

• Criteria for Proficient have been successfully met
• Design is exceptionally detailed
• Design is visually outstanding

3 Proficient

• Quilt design reflects research on African and African American quilting
• Quilt design reflects research on Biddy Mason's road to California
• Quilt design is visually attractive
• Quilt design contains adequate detail
• Quilt design has a professional appearance

2 Progressing

• Three to four of the criteria for Proficient have been met
• Quilt design needs more work

1 Not Yet Meeting the Standard

• Less than three of the criteria for Proficient have been met
• Task should be repeated